I think the comments on
Rediff are, almost as a rule, too loose. I, of all people, have no
problems with looseness as along as it does not embrace malicious stereotyping, racism and
intolerance - esp. in a public space.
I have spotted this problem in
Rediff since years now and have been shocked by the venom. Sample this comment today on article on Rushdie's
introduction to
Desai's In Custody :
ADVISE TO
REDIFFby Rajesh Bhagwat on Dec 07, 2007 11:43 AM
YOU HAVE SEEN RECENTLY WHAT HAPPENED IN
TASLIMA NASREEN CASE.
MOSLEMS ARE BECOMING
GROWINGLY INTOLERANT.ACTION AND REACTION ARE EQUAL AND OPPOSITE, AS PER THE LAWS OF KARMA,
HENCE THEY ARE GONNA FACE EQUALLY FIERCE INTOLERANCE FROM OTHER RELIGIONS AND COMMUNITIES. ONE WORD OF CAUTION TO
REDIFF PEOPLE. NO DOUBT YOU ARE DOING A
GRREAT JOB BUT ILLITERATES
DONT UNDERSTAND THIS. IF YOU GIVE NEWS OF RUSHDIE, THOSE ILLITERATES(OR GRADUATES OF
MADRASSAS) CAN ALSO ISSUE A FATWA AGAINST YOU!!!
This is a sample. It has no relevance to the article. Very soon some Mr. Y will speak about raping Hindu women, deriding the
Gods, then Mr. Z will abuse Allah. Many times their names will be just
that - X, Hindu Lover, Allah, Islam
There are some people who feel that a lot of these comments (that get moderated only hours after the posting) are actually planted by
mischievous (what a nice term for these assholes) elements, incl., as always, our brothers across the border. I agree somewhat : there are some patterns
that keep coming.
And when Hindu Lover asks "Do you think our Gods are really powerful as their mighty one?" I smell a rat
My point is: This is not what free speech means
A protest against rights violation is a free speech
A painting of a "god" in a format unexplored is (
it is also artistic creativity)
But a base abuse, threats and calls for ethnic cleansing - No.
Either
rediff should disallow anonymous comments or moderate them before publishing.
This shit has been going on for too
long.